Trending
Integrity is a word we don't get to use very often. It's probably because of what that word describes: The practice of being honest and showing a consistent and uncompromising adherence to strong moral and ethical principles and values.
We'd like to use that word when it comes to our state Legislature and governor but, unfortunately, it doesn't fit.
Two-thirds of the voters gave them a great opportunity to show their integrity when Proposal 1 was approved last November. A part of this constitutional amendment was enacted to ensure transparency in the operation of state government. It requires lawmakers and state executive officials to file annual financial disclosure reports on their income, assets, liabilities, gifts from lobbyists, positions held in specific organizations and agreements on future employment, beginning on April 15, 2024.
What a great opportunity for state officials to respect the will of the people. What a great opportunity for them to act with dispatch and put those rules into effect as soon as possible. That would have spoken volumes to the voters.
But a year has passed and nothing has changed.
Michigan is one of just two states in the U.S. - Idaho is the other - without a financial disclosure law, according to the Center for Public Integrity. This lack of disclosure is partly why Michigan ranked worst in the country in the comprehensive assessment of state government accountability and transparency.
"Michigan received an F in 10 of the 13 categories of government operations that were examined, including public access to information, political financing and judicial accountability," the Center reported.
"The lack of effective disclosure rules for officials in nearly all facets of state government opens the doors to potential conflicts of interest, but also to potential public corruption," said Daniel Krassner, political director at Represent.Us, a nonpartisan group aimed at passing anti-corruption laws at state and local levels. "Across the country, there are legislators doing business with their state government and benefiting privately from budgets they've built."
Krassner said Michigan especially is at a high risk for corruption by not putting in place commonplace transparency and accountability safeguards. "Disclosure is key to holding politicians accountable," he said.
We couldn't agree more.
When she was campaigning, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer spoke decisively about reform, the need for financial disclosure and transparency in government. Then the Democrats took control of both the House and Senate. So what was stopping them from enacting these reforms?
Now Whitmer is speaking out against stronger spousal disclosure rules, saying they could be disproportionately "held against" female candidates. What a convenient excuse to back off reform. Spousal disclosure rules are critical to transparency because it's easy for a politician to shift funds to a spouse and escape scrutiny if there is no disclosure requirement that extends there.
Under the Senate plan that was OK'd, state lawmakers, the governor, attorney general, secretary of state and candidates for those offices would be required to disclose the source of any income or asset worth at least $1,000. It includes limited disclosure requirements for spouses, proposes significantly smaller fines for lying than a similar congressional law and does not require any disclosure for travel "junkets" paid for by nonprofits.
Meanwhile, the House introduced legislation that would, for the first time, subject them and the governor to public records requests under the state's Freedom of Information Act. Then they decided to take a recess for the rest of the year. That decision may open them up to legal action, since they didn't enact law that was required under the constitutional amendment, which gave them until Dec. 31, 2023.
Perhaps a lawsuit would get their attention, especially if they were ordered by a court to act. Yet it seems like the only way to definitive action in the House is to clean it out.
That said, we aren't surprised to see the governor's sudden twist on financial transparency.
She didn't fix the damn roads either.
-- Traverse City Record-Eagle