Breaking News
Local News

Lawyer: Children are now thriving

By Jenny Lancour 3 min read

ESCANABA -- Looking back over the past year, the attorney who represented the two Rapid River girls who were taken away from their parents and their unsafe and unsanitary home, said she would fight for the children's rights all over again if necessary.

"It was physically, mentally and emotionally draining, and I would do it again to save these girls. It was worth every minute of it," commented Escanaba attorney Jayne Mackowiak following Tuesday's Michigan Court of Appeals decision affirming Delta County Probate Court's termination of the parents' rights last year.

Following a seven-day civil trial in probate court, on Aug. 10, 2017, Judge Robert Goebel Jr. terminated the parental rights of Michael Lavoie, 32, and Tammy Fryer, 31, now of Escanaba, and legally placed the two sisters, now ages 4 and 6, under the custody of the court.

The parents' attorneys and the local Department of Health and Human Services' (DHHS) attorney, County Prosecutor Philip Strom, were in favor of reuniting the family and immediately appealed the termination order. After several months of waiting, on March 6 the case went before three appellate judges who agreed with the local court's ruling on Tuesday.

The parental rights case came to the attention of probate court and DHHS after the couple's youngest daughter, then 3 years old, was found outside lying naked in the snow during below-freezing temperatures on March 17, 2017.

Following further investigation, DHHS and the Delta County Sheriff's Department found the family's home to be unsafe and unsanitary. The two girls were placed under the jurisdiction of the court and cared for by a foster family. During a civil trial last summer, the court ordered the termination of Lavoie and Fryer's parental rights.

Mackowiak said Judge Goebel's 2017 ruling and Tuesday's appeal court opinion were all a team effort resulting in a "slam dunk."

"Tuesday's decision was based on not just the one-time incident of (the girl) out by the Tacoosh River, naked and frankly near death… but all the facts and history of severe abuse and neglect of these two children," she said.

"It was difficult for me to separate emotionally from what I learned and witnessed… It was my job as guardian ad litem to protect these children and to advocate as to what is in their best interest. I did that and Judge Goebel agreed," she added.

"Judge Goebel stated that if it were not for 'Peanut,' the dog, this little girl would have died," recalled Mackowiak, agreeing with the judge that it was "an act of God" the child was found that morning one year ago after Peanut alerted its owner about the girl outside.

During the past year, the two sisters have each progressed significantly under the care of a foster home, said the attorney, who keeps in contact with the foster family which sends her photographs of the girls.

"They look healthy, happy and loved," said Mackowiak. "They are doing well in school. They do have some special needs they are overcoming. In my opinion, they have a wonderful chance for a good life… They are fantastic, funny, loving, silly, happy little girls."

Mackowiak noted the couple's attorneys, DHHS and Strom could appeal Tuesday's appeals court ruling to the Supreme Court of Michigan.

"If they do, I will be there fighting just as hard or harder as I did this past year," she said, admitting this was the most difficult case she's undertaken in her 33-year career.

-- -- --

Jenny Lancour, (906) 786-2021, ext. 143, jlancour@dailypress.net

Starting at /week.