Breaking News
Local News

Judge Goebel cited reasons for decision

By Jenny Lancour 3 min read

ESCANABA -- The Michigan Court of Appeals agreed Tuesday with a 2017 ruling made by Delta County Probate Court Judge Robert Goebel Jr. to terminate the parental rights of a couple whose 3-year-old daughter was found naked outside in Rapid River one year ago.

Looking back on Judge Goebel's ruling, he cited several statutory grounds to justify the termination of the parental rights of Michael Lavoie, 32, and Tammy Fryer, 31, who now reside in Escanaba. Their two daughters, now ages 4 and 6, remain in the care of a foster family while awaiting adoption.

According to Judge Goebel's 37-page ruling issued on Aug. 10, 2017, the parents lied to the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) case worker and committed perjury while testifying under oath about their residences, their finances, and the care of their daughters during their seven-day civil trial.

"The court does not believe the parents would follow court orders to keep the children safe. The long-term serious chronic abuse and neglect also supports this conclusion," stated Goebel in his custody ruling.

In addition to the younger daughter being "saved from certain death" when she was found naked outside on March 17, 2017, DHHS had also investigated a previous incident involving the older daughter being on the roof of the family's home, stated the judge.

Both girls also suffered physical injuries under their parents' care including bruises and scratches, as well as serious tooth decay that required surgery, he said. When the older daughter broke her arm, the parents did not follow up on three therapy appointments, noted Goebel, citing medical concerns that this may have impaired future use of the child's arm.

Goebel also stated the parents were guilty of criminal acts. He cited examples of first-degree, second-degree, third-degree and fourth-degree child abuse because of the physical injuries their daughters suffered, inadequate food and shelter provided for the girls, and physical harm the unfit home posed for the children.

"The court finds each parent knowingly and intentionally caused an act likely to cause serious physical harm to each child regardless of whether the harm resulted," stated Goebel, adding, "The general condition of the home placed the children at risk of serious physical harm… The way the children were forced to live in their home is surely inhumane…"

The judge said the parents failed to provide proper care and custody for each child and there was no reasonable expectation either parent would be able to provide proper care and custody.

"There is reasonable likelihood -- based on the conduct as well as the capacity of each parent -- that each child will be harmed if (they) are returned to the home of either parent," he added.

Goebel concluded, "The court finds each parent poses a significant risk to these children and the court has no confidence that (DHHS) or anyone else is capable of making them or their home safe for the children ever to be returned to."

In the best interest of the children, Goebel's ruling ordered immediate termination, allowing Lavoie and Fryer one final "good-bye" visit with their daughters.

The judge also declared the children as permanent wards of the court, which would oversee the adoption of the sisters without DHHS involvement.

Goebel said DHHS and the prosecutor failed to file for termination of the parents' rights as mandated by state law when a child suffers a life-threatening injury -- such as hypothermia -- or when a parent places a child in harm or in risk of harm -- such as in an unsafe home.

-- -- --

Jenny Lancour, (906) 786-2021, ext. 143, jlancour@dailypress.net

Starting at /week.