Breaking News
Local News

Two recall petitions to be circulated

By Jordan Beck 6 min read

ESCANABA -- Out of four recall petition language submissions related to officials in Garden and Fairbanks townships, two will be able to go forward, the Delta County Election Commission determined during a clarity hearing at the Delta County Probate Courtroom Monday.

"We are here to consider the language for certain recall petitions," Delta County Probate Court Judge Robert Goebel Jr. said at the start of this hearing. Along with Goebel, Delta County Clerk Nancy Kolich and Delta County Treasurer Tom Sabor are members of the commission.

Recall petition language focusing on Supervisor Ronald Collins, Clerk Kathryn Denholm, and Trustee James Dalgord of Fairbanks Township and Supervisor Morgan Tatrow of Garden Township was not approved by the Delta County Election Commission during a clarity hearing in January. The decision was made because members of the commission found the submitted language vague and difficult for voters to understand.

Monday's clarity hearing focused on new recall petition language dealing with the same officials. Garden Township resident Cristi Currie submitted recall petition language dealing with Tatrow, and Fairbanks Township resident Autumn Moore filed the language dealing with the Fairbanks Township officials.

Each of the submissions discussed Monday was related to Heritage Sustainable Energy. In 2012, Heritage completed the construction of 14 wind turbines in Garden Township on the Garden Peninsula. Ever since the wind farm was proposed, the community has been divided over the issue. Heritage is currently planning to build 36 additional turbines in Garden and Fairbanks townships.

The first language submission discussed by the commission Monday dealt with Tatrow. According to the submission, the efforts to recall Tatrow are based on him "voting yes on a motion to grant Heritage Garden Township consent to use Delta County's right of way for construction and operation of an electrical power line without requesting Heritage to provide compensation to the township."

During public comment, Tatrow said the township does not currently have a legal method of charging utility providers for right-of-ways.

"We don't have an ordinance pertaining to charging a fee at this time," he said. He also noted Heritage's use of the right-of-way in question has not yet been approved.

Currie said she believes the township should charge Heritage for the use of the right-of-way.

"They've always given the impression that the wind farm is to bring money into a poor community -- compensation is important," she said.

Goebel noted the commission's role in this situation is limited to determining whether or not the submitted language is clear enough to appear on petitions.

"Our job is not to do an investigation and try to find out who's telling the truth or who isn't," he said. The language dealing with Tatrow was approved unanimously by the commission.

Recall petition language dealing with Denholm was also approved. This language stated that Denholm had made "a motion to give township board consent to Heritage Sustainable Energy to place electrical power lines within the Delta County road right-of-way without the request providing compensation to the township."

Denholm said her motions on this matter did not result in Heritage being able to place these lines within the right-of-way -- she voted to revoke a motion she made in September 2017 during a meeting held the following month, and a motion she made in February 2018 did not receive a second. She felt the submitted language did not make this sufficiently clear.

"I think the wording, in that respect, is misleading, in that I think it leads a reasonable person to believe that I have made a motion which resulted in Heritage receiving consent to use that right-of-way," she said.

Moore, who spoke at the hearing via conference call, said the language she submitted was not inaccurate.

"This statement is factual -- (Denholm) did make a motion to give township board consent to Heritage to place electrical power lines within the Delta County road right-of-way without the township receiving compensation," she said. The language dealing with Denholm was approved unanimously.

However, not every recall petition language submission discussed during the meeting was approved -- including the submission dealing with Collins. According to the language included in this submission, "he discussed the request to the township from Heritage Sustainable Energy for consent to construct electric pole lines in the Delta County road right-of-way without disclosing, at a township meeting, that he had accepted compensation from Heritage for a wind lease."

Collins said this language does not explain if or how these actions were illegal.

"When reading this statement, I believe there will be confusion in a person's mind as to whether Mrs. Moore is actually accusing me of breaking the law or just saying that I did something she doesn't like," he said. Collins had also recused himself from the board when they voted to rescind the motion Denholm made in September 2017, and he has continued to do so during subsequent board discussions on the topic.

Moore noted she wrote the submission with the goal of keeping the rewritten language from running into the same issues the original draft did.

"We learned from the last clarity hearing that this is not a trial … this is just based on facts," she said.

Kolich and Sabor voted to not approve the language dealing with Collins, while Goebel abstained.

The commission unanimously voted to not approve language dealing with Dalgord. The language included in this submission was identical to the language included in the submission dealing with Collins.

"I agree … it has the same issues that his has," Dalgord said.

Like Collins, Dalgord has recused himself from the board when the need arises since October 2017. Kolich also noted she felt the recall petition language submissions regarding Collins and Dalgord did not reflect information included in the meeting minutes presented to the commission.

Currie and Moore will now be able to circulate the petitions dealing with Tatrow and Denholm. The petition related to Tatrow will need 101 signatures to be successful, and the petition related to Denholm will need 39 signatures; these numbers are equal to 25 percent of the turnout for the last gubernatorial election in each township.

The language for these petitions will be valid for 180 days, and signatures must be submitted within 60 days of being received. If they are successful, a special recall vote will take place to fill the affected positions during the next township election after the signatures are submitted. (For this vote to appear on the November 2018 election, the required number of signatures would need to be submitted within about 110 days of the election.)

Moore or another sponsor in Fairbanks Township will be able to develop new language dealing with Collins and Dalgord. They would then be able to submit this language to the election commission.

Starting at /week.