Court hears Nelson parole appeal
Man convicted of 1995 Escanaba murder could be released early
Trending
ESCANABA -- More than three dozen people were present for a parole appeal hearing in Delta County Circuit Court Friday afternoon, but the future of Hans Christian Nelson, who was convicted of murdering his uncle Todd Newman in 1995 in Escanaba, remains undecided.
Two days after a fight at his uncle's home where Nelson was hit over the head with a beer bottle, Nelson broke into Newman's home and killed him with a sawed-off shotgun on Aug. 17, 1995. He was charged with open murder, and later convicted of second-degree murder and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony.
"It was a crime of rage, a young man's response to being bullied," said Attorney Frank Stupak, who had represented Nelson during his trial and returned to argue on his behalf at Friday's hearing.
Nelson was sentenced in 1996 to 25 to 48 years imprisonment for Newman's murder. Including the time served prior to his sentencing, Nelson has been incarcerated since Aug. 18, 1995 -- more than 22 years. In that time, he has been a model prisoner, completing multiple training programs, training leader dogs for the disabled, and only receiving one disciplinary action during his time in prison.
That good behavior qualified Nelson for "disciplinary credit," which, when considered with other factors by the parole board, can allow for a prisoner to be released prior to serving the entirety of their minimum sentence.
It was also noted in court that Nelson had no history of violence while in the prison system, is not currently on any psychiatric medications, and a mental health evaluation indicated that he is not mentally ill or a risk to society.
Individuals who are being considered for parole receive a numeric score by the parole board. Inmates given a plus-3 score are considered has having a probability of parole. Nelson received a plus-14 score, indicating he had a "high probability of parole."
"In this case, this is a person whose record is so good that you don't have what we call 'normal' bad circumstances like family criminality, severe substance abuse problems, no place to live -- none of that is present in this case. That makes him a very good candidate for parole," said Assistant Attorney General Steven Langschwager, who attended Friday's hearing via polycom.
On Sept. 28, 2017, the Michigan Parole Board granted Nelson parole, which was supposed to take effect on Jan. 4 of this year. The appeal to his parole filed by Newman's family suspended his release until a decision can be made by Circuit Court Judge John Economopoulos.
"He's been a good prisoner, but the parole board didn't do their whole job," said Attorney Tony Mancilla, who was in court representing Newman's family.
Chief Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Jessica Pelto argued the parole board had failed to take into account the seriousness of the offense, victim's statements submitted by the family, or whether or not Nelson's release was in the best interest of society and public safety.
"We're talking about a homicide. We're talking about someone who took someone else's life," Pelto told the court.
In addition to Pelto claiming that the parole board had not adequately considered the victim's statements provided to them, she argued the parole board had violated its own administrative rules by not reviewing Nelson's Transition Accountability Plan (TAP). The plans, which were formulated on a prisoner's intake into the prison system, address needs and set goals, tasks, and activities to ensure that a prisoner is prepared to successfully reenter the community upon their release.
"A key component (to the parole board's review) is the Transition and Accountability Plan, which in this case the parole board utterly failed to review," Pelto told the court.
The TAP system, which was phased out by Governor Rick Snyder in 2016, was not instituted until 2009, meaning no TAP plan was created when Nelson was first imprisoned. Documents indicate that a plan was created for Nelson at a later date and that Nelson was assessed using a risk assessment instrument when he was initially incarcerated. However, Nelson's TAP plan was not presented to the parole board for review prior to his parole being granted.
"Yes, Mr. Nelson, might have gone to prison before these new procedures and new plans for prisoner reentry were implemented. However, he's certainly been integrated into that, and he's signed the agreement that he was involved, and the prison was planning for him to be a part of this program, whether it was in place when he got into the prison or not," said Pelto.
Langschwager disagreed that the TAP was necessary in the parole board's decision, citing case law from an unpublished opinion issued Thursday in an unrelated case that addressed how TAP contributed to parole guidelines. Economopoulos was provided with a copy of the opinion for his review.
"They weren't ignoring things. They were considering things. That is what they're supposed to do. They did consider this file fully," said Langschwager.
"It is not beyond reasoned and principled outcomes to parole somebody based on this record with a high parole guidelines score," he added.
Pelto and Mancilla also argued that the parole board ruling did not fully take into account the plan for Nelson after his release. However, it was noted that Nelson had a place to live and job prospects. It was also noted in court that he had family that would support him.
"A lot of people come out of prison with no family support. That is not the case here," said Langschwager.
After hearing the oral arguments, Economopoulos told those present at the hearing that he would meditate over the arguments and the law prior to issuing a written opinion on the parole board's decision. He also reiterated that his decision would not be a re-trying of Nelson's case, but rather a decision based on his authority, the parole board's authority, and the letter of the law.
"I realize this is a case that is hurtful for everybody, and it would be foolish for me to say that I know how you feel, regardless of which side you're on because I don't," he said before thanking those in attendance for conducting themselves civilly.