Breaking News
Local News

Supreme Court Justice visits Esky

By Jenny Lancour 5 min read
Justice Bridget Mary McCormack

ESCANABA -- Michigan's drug courts, sobriety courts and other "problem-solving" courts are proving to be highly successful by addressing behaviors that are most often the reason why defendants are in court in the first place, a Michigan Supreme Court Justice stated while visiting Escanaba on Friday.

Justice Bridget M. McCormack, 51, of Ann Arbor, and the court's six other justices were in Sault Ste. Marie on Wednesday hearing a civil case regarding the standards of care while participating in sports, specifically involving injuries to a golfer who was struck by a golf cart.

While in the Upper Peninsula, Justice McCormack -- who is the Michigan Supreme Court's liaison for tribal courts -- visited four tribal courts in the region including Hannahville Indian Community.

On her return trip to downstate Friday, she stopped at the Delta County Courthouse where she met with judges there and took time to be interviewed by the Daily Press.

As a Supreme Court Justice, McCormack explained, in addition to annually presiding over 70-80 civil and criminal cases -- which are selected from about 2,500 appeals -- the court is responsible for administrating all of the state's trial courts.

This duty includes providing training and materials as well as funding for the state's trial courts and their 145 "problem-solving" courts which address specific issues such as drug and alcohol addictions.

"This is one way our courts can serve the public well," commented McCormack, noting these treatment courts have proven to be incredibly successful in addressing the root of the problem that often leads to criminal behavior.

Delta County has a drug court program. Other examples of "problem-solving" courts include sobriety, veterans and mental health courts.

McCormack said she is mostly involved in veteran treatment courts but has had many opportunities to attend graduation ceremonies in other courts, including recovering drug and alcohol addicts.

"Good news stories are nice to see in the courts," she said, admitting to getting teary-eyed at the graduations.

Regarding her involvement with tribal courts in the state, the justice said efforts are being made to improve relationships between tribal and state courts by having them visit each other and work together so they can learn from one another.

Tribal courts each have their own constitution and are separate from state courts but sometimes cases overlap into each other's jurisdiction, McCormack explained. Common cases where the two courts may have to work together involve child custody issues such as when one parent is a tribal member, she said.

Another example of this partnership is some tribes are working with Michigan courts to allow tribal members to enroll in state treatment programs such as drug and sobriety courts.

"They're working together to use resources in the community to get the most people, the most help," she said.

One Michigan judge downstate sometimes holds "peacemaking court" where all parties involved, including the judge, sit in a circle and take turns talking to work out issues, she added.

McCormack said she enjoys being a Michigan Supreme Court Justice by presiding over cases to help people. She also wants to make sure the state's trial courts have the information and materials to best serve people.

"Mostly, (I enjoy) the ability to try to make a contribution to show how this branch of government can help people by being fair and following the law," she said.

McCormack also said she likes learning about the different issues that come about in the various cases that are argued before the court.

She recalled reviewing the Escanaba case about the dark store issue, which was remanded back to the tax tribunal for more information and resolution.

The justice said she likes handling the criminal cases that come before the Supreme Court because she taught criminal law and continues to teach college law courses but added it's also fun to learn during civil court cases.

She also noted it's important for defendants and plaintiffs to be informed about laws and the legal processes, especially those who cannot afford or do not want to hire an attorney or may not qualify for a court-appointed attorney.

The Michigan Legal Help website is available to educate people and also includes forms and tool kits to assist in the legal process, she said, also noting the website is constantly updated as new laws are enacted or procedures change. New languages are also added to assist those not proficient in English, she added.

"It's important people understand what's happening in court," she said.

McCormack joined the Michigan Supreme Court in January 2013. Before being elected to the eight-year seat, she was a law professor and dean at the University of Michigan Law School.

She is a graduate of the New York University Law School and spent the first five years of her legal career in New York. In 1996, she became a faculty fellow at the Yale Law School and in 1998, she joined the University of Michigan Law School faculty.

-- -- --

Jenny Lancour, (906) 786-2021, ext. 143, jlancour@dailypress.net

Starting at /week.