Breaking News
Local News

League advocates redistricting reform

5 min read

ESCANABA -- The Delta County Chapter of the League of Women Voters (LWV) hosted a redistricting presentation at Bay College in Escanaba Wednesday night. League members Molly Campbell and Mary Cary Crawford were the evening's presenters.

As part of the league's overall goal of educating the public on elections, policies and other governmental functions, Wednesday's session was held to help people understand the possibility of redistricting Michigan's Congressional districts. Over the course of the presentation, Campbell and Crawford discussed the requirements and processes for the drawing of district lines and how sometimes the creation of those lines can be corrupted, ultimately impacting elections. The LWV, along with Voters Not Politicians (VNP), are working to end gerrymandering in the hopes of making the process of drawing district lines fair, transparent, and impartial. Gerrymandering means the lines are drawn in such a way that the results of an election are leaned towards a particular result, or in this case, a certain party in power.

Crawford explained following every census (occurring every 10 years or years that end in zero), the distribution of Congressional seats across the nation are subject to change based on population movement. States are then given the task of drawing the lines for U.S. Congressional and state (House and Senate) districts, noted Crawford, adding every state determines its own process. Currently, Michigan has 14 Congressional districts, 38 state Senate, and 110 state House.

"The Constitution requires the House of Representatives be apportioned to states according the population census," explained Crawford. "But what it doesn't say is how it is done. They leave that up to the states and that's a real important factor."

One thing that is determined to help draw lines at the federal level is the general basis of apportionment should be "one person, one vote," said Crawford. This general rule means the electoral districts must be equal in population according to the most recent census, so each vote is weighted equally. The United States Supreme Court case, "Reynolds v. Sims," in 1964 determined this ruling.

Crawford noted the "one vote, one person" count pertains to everyone including children, people living in a senior living home, prisoners, illegal aliens and immigrants.

"Everyone who responds to the census gets counted," said Crawford.

The Voting Rights Act also helps make sure minorities have their votes recognized in a meaningful way, noted Crawford, adding this blocks district lines that deny minority voters the equal opportunity to take part in the political process.

At the state level in 1963, Michigan established an independent commission that would be in charge of drawing the lines, but in 1966 and 1999, two acts were put into place that established guidelines on how the lines are ultimately drawn today.

As of now, the Michigan Legislature is in charge of creating the Congressional lines, said Crawford. While most of the time the establishment of the district lines are done in private, there is some oversight in Michigan for the approval of the districts. The governor can veto the plans for the Michigan Congressional or Legislative districts, explained Crawford, and the State Supreme Court can review the maps.

Some states already have independent commissions creating lines, such as California, Idaho, Montana, and Washington. However, 26 states put the power solely to the state legislature.

One of the biggest problems with politicians creating the district lines is partisan politicians maybe manipulating elections to keep themselves and their party in power, noted Crawford.

"They can draw the lines and they do it in a very effective way to create districts that are going to vote for candidates of a particular party," said Crawford.

This issue is more commonly known as "gerrymandering," explained Campbell.

While the numbers within each district are relatively the same at 710,000 individuals, the way the lines are drawn can sometimes be skewed and made in odd shapes to accommodate the party in power, noted Campbell.

"The numbers are fair in the sense that there's approximately the same amount of people in each district," said Campbell. "But they will literally manipulate the shape of the district and the constitution doesn't say anything about the shape of the districts. If Democrats are in control, they draw the lines as they wish. Republicans are in control of that state legislature and governorship, they draw the lines how they want."

Campbell showed those in attendance different maps of district lines drawn in the Michigan Senate. The lines tended to "pack and crack" different areas to help sway the vote in the party in power's favor. Because of this, the vast majority of districts aren't competitive and it can impact policies as well as elections, added Campbell.

In December of 2017, the LWVMI and other plaintiffs, filed a lawsuit against Michigan Secretary of State Ruth Johnson in the federal court, explained Campbell. The suit lays out the problem of partisan gerrymandering in Michigan and asks the federal court to declare the current districts in Michigan to be deemed as unconstitutional. VNP filed a petition, gathering 400,000 of the 317,000 signatures required. The signatures are currently awaiting review by the Secretary of State, added Campell.

The ballot initiative by the VNP proposes an Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission (ICRC) that will be made in charge of the redistricting process. If passed, the commission will be made up of four Democrats, four Republicans, and five Independents with representation from across the state, said Campbell. Public hearings will also be a requirement of the ICRC.

Crawford said the LWV supports the ballot initiative because it is working towards voters and their voices being heard.

"The reason they (the league) elected to support this is because they see the current system of redistricting and how it is done is harming voters," said Crawford. "That's one of the things that the league holds very important is voter's rights must be kept safe and fair."

For more information on the redistricting process, visit the LWV website at www.lwv.org or the VNP website at www.votersnotpoliticans.com.

Starting at /week.