Breaking News
Local News

Esky schools continue kindergarten move talks

By Jordan Beck 5 min read

ESCANABA -- Further discussion on consolidating all kindergarten classes into Webster Elementary School in Escanaba was held at the Escanaba School Board's regular meeting Monday.

Board members were given a presentation from Superintendent Coby Fletcher on the topic, which laid out the pros and cons of the move for students, staff, and the district as a whole.

At last week's meeting, Fletcher proposed the idea of making Webster Elementary the only school in the Escanaba district to house begindergarten and kindergarten students. Webster currently enrolls kindergarten through third grade students.

The idea is an alternative to the prior plan of possibly moving the Delta-Schoolcraft Intermediate School District Learning Center (DSISD) into Webster, as discussed at a Feb. 20 meeting.

By combining all of the kindergarten/begindergarten students and staff into one facility, it would create smaller class sizes and make for one "kindergarten center" within the district, said Fletcher.

One of the main reasons for consolidation is declining enrollment numbers throughout the lower elementary schools in Escanaba, explained Fletcher.

If the board decided not to consolidate, the district could look at closing one of its elementary schools based on current enrollment trends, noted Fletcher. If the kindergarten classes were grouped into one building, the district would then look at stabilizing enrollment in Soo Hill and Lemmer Elementary Schools.

"If trends were to continue, and we do nothing, then it's likely we would be within a few years having a discussion about which elementary school we would close," said Fletcher.

Another option to balance student class sizes is to impose boundaries within the district, explained Fletcher. Students would go to the elementary school which they are in distance of in an effort to make numbers in the other schools stable.

Some of the pros that Fletcher listed about consolidating included smaller class sizes, more individual attention for students, creating more teacher communication, and being able to focus on behavioral needs of students. Currently, the average class size for a begindergarten/kindergarten class in Escanaba is 24, which is larger than the average grade school class size.

"We have a definite need to some things, particularly at the lower elementary level, to improve the services we provide," said Fletcher.

Cons to bringing the young students into one facility included the decision to discuss the topic came "late in the game," communication between staff and administration on the idea was lacking, and transitioning both students and staff could be difficult, noted Fletcher.

Changing bus routes, start/end times, and teachers moving classroom equipment would also pose some challenges, added Fletcher. An organizational plan would have to be set in place to make transitions easier.

During the public comment portion of the meeting, a couple of district parents made the point that by shuffling kids around, it add stress to students and remove them from what is familiar. Another commented that by consolidating, it would more than benefit students and staff by creating a more specialized environment for the younger students.

In other business, the board also thoroughly discussed renewing a hockey and swimming co-op with Gladstone Area Schools. The two-year contract for both agreements had to be approved or disapproved by May 1.

Secretary Bob Chaillier, who voted against renewing the hockey co-op agreement, said he felt Escanaba had the numbers to continue a hockey program without Gladstone.

"Being on the school board, I'm a believer in getting away with co-ops especially now with schools of choice, and looking at our sports… we have a lot to offer our kids here in the Escanaba district," said Chaillier. "What bothers me about the hockey co-op is turning our own JV kids from Gladstone and turning our own Escanaba kids away from the team because they might not be as good as a player from Gladstone. I don't feel good about that. It doesn't sit well with me."

Chaillier, along with other board members, also disapproved of the timeline given for discussion of the topic, as they would've liked more time to talk about it.

For the swimming agreement, Chaillier said he agreed this co-op was a need, as both Escanaba and Gladstone don't have the numbers to make a full team without combining students.

Other board members also felt strongly about the co-op, noting that offering other chances to students in other schools brings more people into Escanaba. Vice-president Cathy Jensen asked if the board pulled out of the hockey co-op, if Gladstone would pull out of the swimming co-op agreement. Chaillier said he felt that wouldn't happen because both school districts need each other to make a full swim team.

Upon taking a vote, board members voted unanimously to keep the swimming co-op agreement with Gladstone. Treasurer Robert LaFave was not present. However, the hockey agreement passed narrowly with a vote of 4-2. Chaillier and Trustee April Chaillier voted against the measure.

In other action, board members approved a bid recommendation for the upgrades to the Escanaba High School gymnasium floor. At last week's committee of the whole meeting, Athletic Director Nick Nolde suggested the board approve a bid from Floor Care Concepts out of Grand Rapids, Mich., to strip and re-do the floor. The Escanaba Fan Club is donating the cost of the project which sits at about $30,000.

The Escanaba board will hold a special budget meeting on Wednesday, May 9 at 6 p.m. with a regular meeting to follow on Monday, May 14 at 6 p.m.

Starting at /week.