Breaking News
Local News

Apartment complex decision appealed

By Jenny Lancour 3 min read

ESCANABA -- The developer seeking to construct an apartment complex in downtown Escanaba is appealing the city planning commission's recent decision to not approve the $9.5 million project. The proposal will be considered by the board of appeals on April 24.

Bay de Noc Limited Dividend Housing Association wants to build a four-story, 50,768-square-foot multi-family housing structure on the 1400 block of Ludington Street on the former Northern Motors property. The plan also includes retail space on the first floor.

The Escanaba Planning Commission first reviewed the "Bay de Noc Apartments" proposal on Feb. 8. After reaching a tie vote, commissioners asked the developer to improve the looks of the building's exterior, make adjustments to meet parking requirements, and add more green space.

After making these design changes -- including reducing the number of low- to moderate-income apartments from 44 to 41 units to meet and exceed the parking requirements -- Bay de Noc Limited Dividend Housing Association representative Craig Patterson resubmitted the plan to the commission during a special meeting on Feb. 26.

Despite the project meeting the commissioner's requests and meeting the city's zoning requirements, the commission voted 4-1 against the proposal.

Patterson was seeking approval of the site plan prior to an April 2 application deadline to file for low-income housing tax credits that would help fund the project through the Michigan State Housing Development Authority. The deadline for the next round of applications is Oct. 2.

The project also sought approval from the city for a payment in lieu of taxes and a municipal services agreement.

"I am disappointed in the vote because it totally surprised me," Patterson said in a telephone interview Monday. He noted there is a demand for low-income housing in Escanaba and the plan includes property that will otherwise "sit there for a long time."

According to a "snapshot" market study, which the company conducted, that was followed with a "full blown" market study, the city is in need of affordable housing for working families and individuals, said Patterson, also noting the building will be energy efficient.

"We believe there is a need for affordable housing," he stated. "The people who work every day… they need the kind of housing to raise their families or retire in."

The location is the right site for the apartment complex compared to other properties the company considered in Escanaba, added Patterson, also pointing out there are a lot of empty buildings on Ludington Street.

"We believe that our investment on that site is a great use of the site," he said. "We think our plan… everything we're doing is per the zoning code."

City Manager Patrick Jordan said, when the city's board of appeals reviews the site plan next month, it will make its own decision whether or not to approve the project.

If the zoning board okays the plan, the proposal will go before city council for consideration; if the zoning board does not approve the plan, that decision can be appealed in Delta County Circuit Court, explained Jordan.

The appeals board will meet at 6 p.m. on April 24 at city hall.

The six-member board of appeals has the power to hear and decide appeals on matters where the zoning ordinance provides for review of an administrative interpretation, exception, or special approval permit. The board can also authorize a variance from the strict application of the zoning ordinance.

-- -- --

Jenny Lancour, (906) 786-2021, ext. 143, jlancour@dailypress.net

Starting at /week.